On Thu, Jan 5, 2012 at 13:25, Jani Nikula <jani@nikula.org> wrote: > Bikeshedding topic #1: How about making replying to just the sender the default > in "notmuch reply", and having --reply-all option (instead of --no-reply-all)? > > Bikeshedding topic #2: How about binding 'r' to reply to just the sender by > default, and making 'R' reply-all (instead of vice versa)? I like both these suggestions. This would bring the notmuch behavior in line with gmail, which is what I tend to expect. Mark Walters brings up a good point, that there is a question of what to do when the user tries to reply to their own email. When I do this, what I intend is to send another email to the last person I emailed in the thread, so I think the suggested heuristic of looking at other headers would work. But, maybe others have a different expectation in this case?