Navin Kabra <navin@smriti.com> writes:

> In the meantime, would anyone be interested in investigating this 
> inconsistency so see if this is a notmuch bug that needs fixing? 
> I'd be happy to run any commands and post the output.

If you can reproduce the situation, starting from a fresh database,
let us know exactly how. Otherwise it's not really feasible to debug,
IMHO.