First, I'm aware that such munging is A Bad Thing http://www.unicom.com/pw/reply-to-harmful.html but a lot of lists do it anyway (mostly to work around widely used mailers with lame defaults). After munging, we get headers looking like this From: Some User <some.user@example.com> To: Sample users list <sample-users@sample.org> Reply-To: Sample users list <sample-users@sample.org> Notmuch reply produces To: Sample users list <sample-users@sample.org>, Sample users list <sample-users@sample.org> Handling this is a bit messy, I think we want the current behavior unless To matches Reply-To, in which case we use From and Reply-To. If this is indeed the least bad behavior, I will make a patch for it. Jed